Sugar Hearts

Thursday, February 2, 2012

Cross stitch market is quickly approaching! Barb and I are busy to say the least. Our newest book is almost ready to go to the printer. This recipe is in the book, but I wanted to share this cookie now because it's so good and just right for Valentine's Day. I've done these in several colors. The pink is nice....but these look great in blue too.


First I purchased several heart shape cookie cutters. The one on the upper left shows the original shape. (Actually, the one above is for another cookie recipe in the book....but you get the idea of how to remold the cutter from the picture. I used a 3" cutter for the sugar heart recipe.) These cookie cutters can be changed into a whimsical, one-of-a-kind, heart shape. The soft metal is easily remolded when pressed firmly with your fingers. I moved the sides in a bit to narrow the heart and pressed the concave “V” shape of the cutter down, making a deeper cut into the top of the heart. Take care to keep the top convex curves of the heart shape rounded. The picture above shows the new shape of the cookie cutter.

 The cookie spreads a bit after baking, so I cut each one out again with the cookie cutter while they were still warm to get the perfect shape. I know that seems a bit obsessive....but I wanted them all to be exact. Not to worry about the excess portions of the cookie....think of them like "cookie fries."

Gather all the bits of cookie left over.

Put them into a cute container. Add frosting, and they will be the perfect treat. (Just want you to cookie bits are wasted here!!!)

I made a template of the cookie cutter using plastic template material. (You can purchase the plastic at your local quilt shop.)

Next, I drew a 1/2" grid on the plastic template with a pencil. Where the lines intersected I punched a hole with my handy hole punch. Set the template aside until you are ready for frosting.

The frosting is a powdered sugar glaze. I spread it on with a flat paint brush. While the frosting is still wet,
 I held the template over the cookie and sprinkled the nonpareils from a spoon. It felt like I had more control over their distribution....although who can really control nonpareils? The glaze dries and you are left with cookies that look designed. I love the look of these!!!

The nonpareil placement isn't perfect....but they still are sweet.

Two tips before starting the recipe.

1. Scoop up your flour with a tablespoon and fill the measuring cup. Scrape away the excess flour with a straight edge. This will prevent using too much flour and making your cookies dry.

2. Roll the cookies out between parchment paper. No need to add extra flour to prevent sticking.

Sugar Hearts


1 1/2 cups of confectioners’ sugar
1 cup Land O’Lakes butter
1 egg
1 teaspoon vanilla
1/2 teaspoon almond extract
2 1/2 cups all purpose flour
1 teaspoon baking soda
1 teaspoon cream of tartar

Frosting Ingredients

1 cup of confectioners’ sugar
1/4 teaspoon salt
1/2 teaspoon vanilla
2 tablespoons half and half (more if needed to get the right consistency)
1 drop of food coloring (soft gel paste - AmeriColor #164 Electric Pink)
Tiny nonpareils - white


-Mix the sugar and butter. Add the egg and flavorings. Mix thoroughly with your electric mixer.
-Stir the dry ingredients together and add to the mixer 1 cup at a time.
-Gather the dough into a ball. Half the dough and form each half into a disk. Place the disks into a plastic bag and refrigerate for 4 hours or until the dough is chilled.
-Preheat the oven to 325 degrees.
-Place 1/2 of a chilled disk between two pieces of parchment paper and roll the dough out to 3/16” thick. Keep the remainder of cookie dough in the refrigerator until you are ready to use it. Remove the top parchment paper and use your cookie cutter to cut out the heart shapes. Place the hearts on parchment covered cookie sheets. Gather the remaining dough and roll again for more hearts.
-Bake until the cookie begins to lightly brown on the edges, about 15 minutes. Cut the cookies again with the cookie cutter while the cookies are warm for a perfect heart shape. Remove the extra bits of dough from the cookie. Slide the parchment paper with the cookies onto a rack to cool. Repeat with the remaining dough.

Makes about 4 dozen cookies. Allow the cookie frosting to dry and then package in a airtight container. These will last about 15 minutes.

Until later sweet hearts!



  1. Looking forward to the new book! Thanks for the recipe.

  2. These cookies look wonderful! I really like how you have customised the shape of the cutter, very cool idea :-)
    Thanks for sharing x

  3. Yummyyy cookies,,thank you for the recipe :)
    Love cucki xxx

  4. Cookie Fries! Love it! Can't wait to see the new book -

  5. Love, love, love them. Thank you so much for sharing! I'll be making some for my sweetie!

  6. Yummy! I swear, everything you do is perfect! Thanks for the recipe. Will get DH to try his hand at the baking part at least. :D

  7. SO Sweet! Thank you!!!!

  8. Thank you! Love the stenciling idea for sprinkle placement!

  9. Your designs have been and continue to be coveted. These cookies look yummy! Please contact me, The Sampler Guild of Georgia President, as we would like to discuss teaching possibilities. I would have emailed you directly but couldn't find an email address for Blackbird Designs. Thank you in advance for your response! Diana Lappin

  10. Thank you for the recipe Alam! I am looking forward to your new book!! Missed your postings!!

  11. I'll bet the cookies taste as good as they look! Just finished my "Breakfast in Bed" bed runner last night. Love it. Took it to the quilter this afternoon. You are keeping me busy with all your beautiful new books! Taught the sewing box class last Saturday. Everyone loved it.

  12. I have many,many heart cookie cutters I have been collectiing for years. I can't wait to try your cookie recipe and make a varity of shapes. Love the cookie fries too!

  13. L O V E the idea for the second cutting!!! I'm going to do this for sure! Thanks for sharing.

  14. Those cookies look wonderful! And I love how you "remade" the heart cookie cutter into a more unusual shape. Thanks for the recipe!
    Linda Kay

  15. Thanks for the recipe - they look so yummy!

    hugs, Kaye xoxox

  16. Fun cookies. Can't wait to make them :)

  17. Thank you for the wonderful idea about reshaping the cookie cutter. I too am a collector of many small cutters. Your recipe looks so good. & great dot template idea.I look forward to your new book. bee-hugs, Debby

  18. These are such fun to make. I followed your recipe and they were a huge success. I posted your post on my blog and I had many friends follow...THEY CAN'T wait for your book! and they loved the cookies!!!!! I also look forward to your book!

  19. Those cookies look so pretty and yummy!

  20. thank you for sharing article!Looking forward to the new book! Thanks for the recipe!

  21. The percentages would increase in course of time. Useful information indeed. Thanks.


Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.